Tuesday, October 11, 2005

Are Journalism and Patriotism Mutually Exclusive

The PX was out of news magazines the other day so I bought a copy of Newsweek where I ran across an article titled "Unholy Allies", the gist of which (strategically dated 26 September, 9 days after the parlimentary elections in Afghanistan) is the increasing violence and effectiveness of the Taliban fighters along with their close links to Al Queda insurgents in Iraq. 

 

What boggles my mind about this article is that the Newsweek staff can apparently make an appointment to meet with Al Queda leadership in Afghanistan at any given moment.  They have taken to dropping the "Al" and refering to the ultra-extremist terror sponsoring organization as just "Queda".  Kind of a nick name between buddies.  But then why wouldn't these two organizations be on the best of terms?  After all, it was Newsweek that spawned the rioting in Afghanistan which killed 19 people over the stories of Koran desecration at Guantanemo Bay which were exaggerated at best.  (See "Priveliges and Responsibilities")

 

Sami Yousafzai and Ron Moreau, the authors of this article, give surprising creedence to anything their Taliban contacts tell them while brushing off any explanation or response from the U.S. military.  It seems amazing to me that this article, boasting of a 300% increase in this local Taliban commander's force, and increased liaison with Al Queda (excuse me "Queda") in Iraq had never heard of this letter written by an Al Queda leader which admits defeat in Afghanistan.  But then, "Unholy Allies" goes to great lengths to imply increasing levels of violence when by all credible counts, hostile actions in Afghanistan have decreased more than 50% since the September 17th elections.  Immediately after this little bit of creative writing quotes the Taliban commander's spike in troop strength, it points out that 2005 has been the deadliest year for Americans in Afghanistan since 2001 with 51 killed.  This jump in fatalities is credited largely to "shaped charge IEDs", a technology imported from Iraq.  The reality is that 33 of these 51 fatalities were in helicopter crashes, one due to weather, the other to hostile fire but nowhere near this commanders region, and in no related to shaped charge IEDs.

 

I remember watching a documentary on reporters in the Vietnam war when I was in college in which a panel of journalists was given the scenario of being allowed to imbed with North Vietnamese troops and sitting in ambush of an American patrol.  The question was asked of each of them "Are you a journalist first, or an American?  Would you let the Americans die or would you try to warn them first."  I remember being sickened when most answered that they were journalists first.  Strange that they would say that as citizens of one of the very few countries that would protect them as such. 

 

The people that were so willingly interviewed by our friends from Newsweek in September, attacked an American patrol in October.  One of our soldiers lost both of his legs during the attack and subsequently died of his injuries.  That means he bled to death in a dark hostile land half a world from home even after all the help his friends could give him and the best medical treatment we had available.  Perhaps if Newsweek had been a little more American and a little less journalist, things might be different.

 

It's clear that Newsweek's intent with this article is to sow doubt and malcontent about our progress in Afghanistan.  This is precisely the intent of the Taliban's information campaign.  The only way that they can win this war is if America loses her will and the fastest way for that to happen is through irresponsible yet constitutionally protected journalism like this. 

 

The Schismatics in Dante's "Inferno", those who sowed discord during their lifetime, were punished throughout eternity in the 7th circle of hell by by being cleaved nearly in two allowed to heal before the process is repeated.  I would like to think that I am not a vindicative person, but someone will have to explain to me why I should not wish this punishment on the likes of Newsweek.

 

4 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
SPC Richardson said...

I was referred to your blog. I think I have a helpful resource that you can use for your readership. US Central Command has a website, http://www.centcom.mil, with the latest news and photos from Operation Iraqi Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom. It features the “hard to find” stories from the Middle East, as well as an interesting “What extremists are saying” section. You’re welcome to use any materials you find on our site, please just include the standard attribution to CENTCOM.

You can also sign up for the weekly electronic newsletter and monthly Coalition Bulletin at http://www.centcom.mil/newsletter/newsletter-signup.asp. If you’d like me to subscribe you, just ask.

Lastly, if you could include a link to CENTCOM, that would be appreciated.

All the best,




Spc Richardson
US Central Command Public Affairs

devildog6771 said...

Your feelings are entirely justified. As far as being vindictive, do you really think they give a rats behind how what they are doing endangers your life and the life of your fellow soldiers?

As far as I am oncerned the media pracitces censorship. First Amendment rights are theirs under the Constitution. However the Constitution doesn't give them the right to commit treason or guarentee them immunity for commision of crimes.

MKL said...

It's not a new phenomenon:

"I hate newspapermen. They come into camp and pick up their camp rumors and print them as facts. I regard them as spies, which, in truth, they are. If I killed them all there would be news from Hell before breakfast." -- William T. Sherman